Health Care Reform Will Help Everybody (Barbara O’Brien)

[Guest blogger Barbara O'Brien blogs regularly at The Mahablog, Crooks and Liars, AlterNet, and elsewhere on the progressive political and health blogophere. She has also been a panelist at Netroots Nation and a featured guest blogger at the Take Back America Conference in Washington, DC.]

Many Americans assume the new health care reform act will benefit mostly the poor and uninsured and hurt everyone else, according to polls. As Matt Yglesias wrote, “Basically, people see this as a bill that will take resources from people who have health insurance and give it to people who don’t have health insurance.” Those who still oppose the reform say that people ought to pay for their own health care.

We all believe in the virtues of hard work and self-reliance, but these days it’s a fantasy to think that anyone but the mega-wealthy will not, sooner or later, depend on help from others to pay medical bills. And that’s true no matter how hard you work, how much you love America, or how diligently you take care of yourself. The cost of medical care has so skyrocketed that breaking an arm or leg could cost as much as a new car. And if you get cancer or heart disease — which can happen even to people who live healthy lifestyles — forget about it. The disease will not only clean you out; it will leave a whopping debt for your survivors to pay.

And the truth is, we all pay for other peoples’ health care whether we know it or not. When people can’t pay their medical bills, the cost of their health care gets added to everyone else’s bills and insurance premiums. When poor people use emergency rooms as a doctor of last resort, their care is not “free.” You pay for it.

Another common fantasy about medical care is that the “free market” provides incentives for medical companies to develop innovative new drugs and treatments for disease without government subsidy. It’s true that private enterprise is very good at developing profitable health care products. But not all medical care can be made profitable.

For years, the U.S. government has been funding medical research that the big private companies don’t want to do because there is too much cost for the potential profit. This is especially true for diseases that are rare and expensive to treat. An example of a recent advance made possible by government grants include new guidelines for malignant pleural mesothelioma treatment developed by MD Anderson Cancer Center researchers. Another is a blood screening test developed by mesothelioma doctors like thoracic surgeon Dr. David Sugarbaker. The health reform act provides for more dollars for such research, from which even many of the tea party protesters will benefit.

The biggest fantasy of all was that people who had insurance didn’t have to worry about health care costs. But the fact is that in recent years millions of Americans have been bankrupted by medical costs, and three-quarters of the medically bankrupt had health insurance. And yes, insurance companies even dumped hard-working, law-abiding patriots. But the health care reform act will put an end to that, and now America’s hard-working, law-abiding patriots are more financially secure, whether they like it or not.

Shorter Yglesias

::…Don’t really care what complicated schemes you come up with to pass health care, as long as you Git Er Done….::

[All due appreciation to the guys who are always credited by the guys at Sadly No! for the whole "Shorter" concept, being aware of all internet traditions and such ... and that Cable Guy too.]

If you have to dumb things “up” for the peanut brains on the right that still insist tax-cuts are always the answer, just so it looks too weird for the easily bamboozled to understand, so be it.  They know single payer is the only thing that really works, even though it’s too French for their taste.

Dress it down, mix it up, pull it and squeeze it from five different sides.  Just do some fucking thing and we can all tell you why it won’t work and why single-payer is the only thing that will.  One way or another you got to get rid of the profit motive or by definition, someone is going to get ripped off, which will create some other bunch of fuckers who will become too big too fail through this windfall.

Chill Out: It’s The Flu, Not The Plague

Close The Borders!!

Buy Duck Tape and Stay In Your Safe Room!

Stock Up on Ammo and Surgical Masks!

DON’T KISS PIGS!!!!!!

Worldwide, the annual death toll from the [plain old "regular"] flu is estimated to be between 250,000 and 500,000.

Twice in as many days, the acting Director of the Centers for Disease Control noted that the U.S. averages about 36,000 annual deaths from seasonal flu every year — the kind of flu you’ve had before and lived to complain about.  98 Americans die of “normal” influenza every day — day after day.

Tragic that it is for 150 people to have died so far from this H1N1 “swine” flu strain, let’s say the Mexico outbreak ends up ten times worse than it is now, resulting in 1,500 total deaths.  Let’s also reduce the affected population to just the greater Mexico City population — The largest metro area in the western hemisphere at 22 million — which might see as many as 40% catching this bug according to one of the latest alarmist headlines.

So, instead of taking the entire Mexican population of 111 million seeing only 150 deaths, let’s look at a worse-case/inflated situation of 1,500 deaths among 22 million people.  That’s somewhere in the range of 0.007% mortality rate assuming a limited population and increase in deaths from this outbreak rising ten-fold.

Compare that 0.007% mortality rate to the plain old flu in the United States with her 36,000 annual flu deaths among a 306 million population.  It works out 0.012% mortality rate, or almost twice what we could expect if the Mexico outbreak is ten-times worse than now reported.

That this is a grossly inflated estimate is nicely illustrated by the annual number of Mexican AIDs deaths the CIA Factbook reports, 11,000, or 73 times the 150 deaths the H1N1 flu strain has killed to date.  Last I heard, AIDs is a lot more deadly and a lot harder to transmit than any sort of flu.

I think we’re going to be okay folks.  I’d be more worried about drinking the water in Mexico than the flu-carrying islamo-bioterror invasion.  Unless of course I watched Glenn Beck without being reduced to fits of laughter.